The National Football League (NFL) is a multibillion-dollar industry, revered by fans across the globe for its high-stakes drama, electrifying games, and storied franchises. However, behind the scenes, not all organizations are created equal. While successful teams often thrive under stable, visionary ownership, others languish in mediocrity or chaos due to the missteps of dysfunctional owners. From erratic decision-making to fostering toxic cultures, the impact of such owners reverberates throughout the league, affecting players, fans, and the league’s reputation as a whole.
The Role of Ownership in NFL Success
In professional sports, ownership is one of the most critical determinants of a team’s success. A good owner provides financial resources, hires competent leadership, and fosters a culture of accountability and excellence. They know when to delegate and allow general managers and coaches to do their jobs. Teams like the New England Patriots under Robert Kraft, the Kansas City Chiefs under the Hunt family, and the Pittsburgh Steelers under the Rooney family exemplify the benefits of steady, well-informed ownership.
Conversely, dysfunctional owners often do the opposite. They meddle in football operations without the necessary expertise, make impulsive decisions, and prioritize personal agendas over the team’s success. These actions can destabilize franchises, alienate fans, and hinder long-term growth.
Symptoms of Dysfunctional Ownership
Poor Hiring Decisions
Dysfunctional owners frequently hire underqualified general managers or head coaches based on personal relationships, flashy resumes, or hasty reactions to public pressure. Without a coherent strategy, these hires often lead to high turnover, instability, and wasted potential.
Example: The Cleveland Browns endured years of instability, cycling through coaches and executives under various owners before their recent resurgence. Consistent turnover made it nearly impossible to build a competitive roster or establish a winning culture.
Micromanagement
Owners who meddle in day-to-day football operations—drafting players, dictating game plans, or undermining coaches—disrupt the chain of command and erode trust within the organization.
Example: The Dallas Cowboys under Jerry Jones have been a perennial source of debate. While Jones is undoubtedly passionate about the team, his insistence on serving as general manager has led to inconsistent results, despite significant talent on the roster.
Toxic Workplace Culture
Dysfunctional owners can create or enable toxic environments, marked by harassment, lack of accountability, and high employee turnover. These issues often extend beyond football and tarnish the team’s reputation.
Example: Daniel Snyder’s tenure as owner of the Washington Commanders was plagued by allegations of a hostile workplace, financial mismanagement, and poor treatment of employees. The resulting scandals alienated fans and led to an eventual forced sale of the team.
Short-Term Thinking
Prioritizing quick fixes—such as overpaying free agents, trading away draft picks, or firing coaches prematurely—can create a vicious cycle of failure. This approach often ignores the importance of building a sustainable foundation for long-term success.
Example: The New York Jets’ frequent coaching changes and questionable roster moves in recent years have kept them in a perpetual rebuilding phase, despite flashes of promise.
The Fallout of Dysfunctional Ownership
On-Field Performance
Teams with dysfunctional owners often struggle to maintain consistency and competitiveness. Without a cohesive vision, even talented rosters can underperform, leaving fans frustrated and players disheartened.
Fan Alienation
Few things frustrate fans more than watching their team fail due to mismanagement. Poor decision-making and a lack of accountability can lead to dwindling ticket sales, declining merchandise revenue, and a shrinking fan base.
Example: Once one of the NFL’s proudest franchises, the Commanders saw their attendance and fan enthusiasm plummet during Snyder’s ownership.
Player Development and Retention
Dysfunctional organizations often fail to develop their young talent effectively or provide a stable environment for veterans. Players may seek to leave via free agency or demand trades to escape poorly run franchises.
League Reputation
While the NFL is built on parity and competition, poorly run teams diminish the league’s overall quality. Persistent dysfunction within certain franchises can tarnish the NFL’s image and lead to calls for more oversight.
How the NFL Can Address Dysfunctional Ownership
Stronger Oversight
The NFL could implement stricter accountability measures for owners, ensuring they meet professional standards. This might include requiring franchises to undergo periodic evaluations or enforcing penalties for consistent underperformance.
Encouraging Diverse Ownership Groups
Welcoming more diverse ownership groups could bring fresh perspectives and innovative management strategies to the league. Teams like the Denver Broncos, with their diverse ownership structure under Rob Walton, are setting a new precedent.
Supporting Transparency
League-wide transparency initiatives regarding workplace culture and operations can help hold owners accountable and ensure all teams meet minimum standards.
Fan Advocacy
Fans are the lifeblood of the NFL, and their voices matter. Boycotts, petitions, and vocal criticism can pressure dysfunctional owners to improve their management—or, in extreme cases, sell their teams.
Why It Matters
Dysfunctional ownership is a shadow that looms over some of the NFL’s most storied franchises. While the league thrives on the passion and commitment of its players and fans, a poorly run organization can undermine even the most dedicated efforts. As the NFL continues to evolve, it’s crucial to address the issues stemming from mismanagement at the ownership level.
At its best, football is about teamwork, strategy, and excellence—qualities that should be reflected not just on the field but in the boardroom as well. With better oversight, accountability, and forward-thinking leadership, the league can ensure that every franchise fulfills its potential, creating a better experience for players and fans alike. After all, the success of the NFL depends on the strength of its entire ecosystem, and that begins at the top.
Learn more at: https://www.nfl.com/photos/team-owners-of-the-nfl-09000d5d824c9f3c#d98c5922-5d32-4a7b-985f-6ede94278b0e
Serena and Venus Williams: Pioneering Equity and Representation in the NFL
The Sport Lady has been a lifelong sports enthusiast. She believes that sports have the power to unite people, create common bonds, and foster shared experiences. As a wife and mother of sports lovers, she is passionate about her favorite teams and cherishes every opportunity to watch them play. For her, every day is game day!